All Joy and No Fun

The Paradox Of Modern Parenthood

by Jennifer Senior

Number of pages: 320

Publisher: Ecco

BBB Library: Parenting

ISBN: 9780062072221



About the Author

Jennifer Senior is a contributing editor at New York magazine, where she writes profiles and cover stories about politics, social science, and mental health. She won the Front Page Award from the Newswomen’s Club of New York for magazine feature writing in 1999.

Read More...

Editorial Review

Over the past two generations, parenthood has gone through radical readjustments. As children went from helping on the farm to being the focus of relentless cosseting, they shifted from being our “employees” to our “bosses!” Even the most organized people have little to do to prepare themselves for having children. They can buy all the books, observe friends and relations, review their own memories of childhood, but the distance between those proxy experiences and the real thing, ultimately, can be measured in light years. Prospective parents have no clue what their children will be like; no clue what it will mean to have their hearts permanently annexed; no clue what it feel like to second-guess so many seemingly simple decisions, or to be multitasking even while they’re brushing their teeth. Becoming a parent is one of the most sudden and dramatic changes in adult life. A father with two young kids describes the whole experience as “All Joy and No Fun.” This might be familiar with the description used by the social scientist William Doherty which summarizes parenting: “a high-cost / high-reward activity.” There’s no denying that our lives as fathers and mothers have grown much complex, and we still don’t have a new set of scripts to guide us through them. Even scholars are mainly concerned with the effect of parents on their children. But it’s time now to swing the telescope around and ask this question from the reverse perspective: What is the effect of parenthood on adults? After all, we’re all the sum of our experiences. Raising children plays an enormous part in shaping our vision and making us who we are.

Book Reviews

"As children went from helping on the farm to being the focus of relentless cosseting, they shifted “from being our employees to our bosses,” Jennifer Senior observes in her trenchant and engrossing first book, All Joy and No Fun." The New York Times

"All Joy and No Funexplores how children affect their parents and why decades of social science show that parents aren’t any happier, and in some cases are less happy, than people without kids." Washington Post

Books on Related Topics

Wisdom to Share

“Being a parent” is much more difficult for social science to anatomize.

But now, parents live in a society that gives them the sense that their kids have to give them permission to do things.

This technological change is happening so rapidly it’s hard for parents to keep up.

Adolescence creates a dramatic discontinuity in the entire family system.

During adolescence, questions of preference start to bleed into questions of morality and safety.

Ingratitude is already one of the biggest heartaches of child-rearing.

The contemporary home has become a place of perpetual liminal tension, with everyone trying to work out whether adolescents are adults or kids.

As children get older, they crave independence, agency, a sense of their own purpose.

Mothers of adolescents are much more likely to be experiencing distress.

When prospective mothers and fathers imagine the joys of parenthood, they seldom imagine the adolescent years.

Happiness is quite intangible; it’s only a precious by-product of worthwhile activities.

it’s unrealistic to assume that if all goes well in a child’s life, he’ll be happy.

The goal of parenting has become simple – to raise happy, healthy, well-adjusted kids.

Being considered precious and irreplaceable gave children more power in the family hierarchy than they had ever had.

Today, we’re far less clear about what “parenting” entails.

extravagant parental involvement in the children’s activities and life routines is referred to as “concerted cultivation.”

It’s fine, though, not to find an answer; after all, questions are the true revelation, not the answers.

Parents are often baffled when their children ask questions about something so basic as time.

Sometimes deadlines exist more in our minds than they do on the ground.

Women’s social networks shrink in the early years of child-rearing.

Children generate more arguments than any other subject.

But they are also much more prone to conflict.

It’s a fact that children strengthen the relationship between parents and make them less apt to divorce.

Decline in marital satisfaction after the birth of the first child.

The most dramatic consequence of having children is the change in our relations and marriages.

The difficulty is that they allow many “professionals” to work from home, reducing their ability and chance to develop and get promoted!

The difficulty is that they allow many “professionals” to work from home, reducing their ability and chance to develop and get promoted!

Adults find children a bit difficult to synchronize with their own agendas.But most of life with young children doesn’t have a script.

The extravagance of children’s wishes, behaviors, and energies all become a threat to the parents’ well-ordered lives.

When parents spend a great deal of time fighting their urge to sleep, they are more vulnerable to scream and yell, and then feel mad at themselves!

Raising children plays an enormous part in shaping our vision and making us who we are.

Becoming a parent is one of the most sudden and dramatic changes in adult life.

Even the most organized people have little to do to prepare themselves for having children.

Over the past two generations, parenthood has gone through radical readjustments.